Jerod Haase has had many saving graces in recent years - evidently working hard, being a nice guy, having powerful patrons, coaching at a time of change in the national landscape that built in excuses, going a few years of not being the major sports coach who had grown most stale. Another is that his individual teams aren't horrendous. Mediocre is the word many reach for. Consider the KenPom rankings of his tenure among 350+ (currently 362) major basketball programs and 80 Power Six teams:
2017: #102 (#8 in Pac-12)
2018: #87 (#7 in Pac-12)
2019: #112 (#10 in Pac-12)
2020: #43 (#4 in Pac-12)
2021: #57 (#8 in Pac-12)
2022: #106 (#8 in Pac-12)
2023: #84 (#9 in Pac-12)
2024: #90 (#8 in Pac-12)
Below average almost every year but also squarely in the mediocre middle of the Pac-12 almost every year. Falling outside of the top 100 happens less than half the time and he's never had a horrendous team. Many call that mediocre.
To me being below average 87.5 percent of the time is much, much worse than mediocre. But I've said that before and don't want to be a broken record. To try to add something new, I thought I'd look at the 80 Power Six programs and look at the coaches who have been around as long as Haase to try to put into context whether Haase is an outlier (ok, how much he's an outlier) in terms of the rope he's gotten to deliver these results. NCAA tournament appearances since 2017 of the guys who have coached the whole span (parenthetically listing how this year is going):
Matt Painter (Purdue) - 6 (arguably best team in the country)
Bill Self (Kansas) - 6 (very high seed)
Tom Izzo (Michigan State) - 6 (making the tournament)
Kelvin Sampson (Houston) - 5 (arguably best team in the country)
Greg McDermott (Creighton) - 5 (very high seed)
Rick Barnes - 5 (Tennessee) - 5 (very high seed)
Scott Drew (Baylor) - 5 (making the tournament)
John Calipari (Kentucky) - 5 (making the tournament)
Tony Bennett (Virginia) - 5 (fringe of the bubble)
Greg Gard (Wisconsin) - 4 (very high seed)
Bruce Pearl (Auburn) - 4 (very high seed)
Fran McCaffery (Iowa) - 4 (outside the bubble)
Jim Larranaga (Miami) - 4 (outside the bubble)
Leonard Hamilton (Florida State) - 4 (outside the bubble)
Andy Enfield (USC) - 4 (well outside the bubble)
Jamie Dixon (TCU) - 3 (inside the bubble at the moment)
Dana Altman (Oregon) - 3 (inside the bubble at the moment)
Bobby Hurley (Arizona State) - 3 (well outside the bubble)
Brad Brownell (Clemson) - 2 (likely to make tournament)
Chris Collins (Northwestern) - 2 (inside the bubble at the moment)
Steve Pikiell (Rutgers) - 2 (well outside the bubble)
Tad Boyle (Colorado) - 1 (inside the bubble at the moment)
Wayne Tinkle (Oregon State) - 1 (massively outside the bubble)
Jerod Haase (Stanford) - 0 (well outside the bubble)
Johnny Dawkins (UCF) is now a Power Six coach but this is the first year of that in this stretch. But even he's made a tournament in this stretch, and is coaching a better team than Stanford this year.
Only at Stanford. Let's have some pride. We can succeed on the level of Northwestern, Rutgers, Colorado, Oregon State, and UCF.