Here are the dual-threat QBs listed as 5-stars under 247 Sports composite rankings. I think these are a greater predictor of success (certainly within college) because of the prevalence of the spread offenses in college...
2001
D.J. Shockley - Georgia - First-Team All-SEC - 7th round - Falcons - NFL back-up for 4.5 years
Cecil Howard - Syracuse - no impact in college (transferred twice, ending up at Northeastern)
2002
Vince Young - Texas - consensus All-American - 1st round - Titans - 2-time Pro-Bowler
Marcus Vick - Virginia Tech - starter in 2005, but dismissed from team in 2006 because of legal troubles
James Banks - Tennessee - converted to WR, then transferred to Carson-Newman
2003
Robert Lane - Ole Miss - converted to H-Back/TE - not drafted
2004
Xavier Lee - Florida St. - had a few starts - not drafted
Matt Tuiasosopo - Washington - signed to play baseball, and has had stints with the Mariners and Tigers
Bobby Reid - Oklahoma St.- started for parts of 2 seasons - not drafted
2005
Ryan Perilloux - LSU - had a few promising starts - dismissed from LSU because of legal troubles and transferred to Jacksonville St. - not drafted - has made a few practice squads
2006
Tim Tebow - Florida - Heisman Trophy winner - odd NFL career
2007
Tyrod Taylor - Virginia Tech - multi-year starter and ACC player of the year - 6th round - Ravens - recently signed with the Bills
2008
Terrelle Pryor - Ohio St. - multi-year starter and runner up for Big 10 MVP - 3rd round (supplemental) - Raiders - recently converted to WR for the Browns
E.J. Manuel - Florida St. - multi-year started and 2nd team All-ACC - 1st round - Bills
2009
Russell Shepard - LSU - converted to WR - undrafted, but signed as free agent with Buccaneers - has played as a special teams player
Aaron Murray - Georgia - multi-year starter - SEC career passing leader - 5th round - Chiefs
2010
None
2011
Jeff Driskel - Florida - started a number of games, but not good - transferred to Louisiana Tech this year
Braxton Miller - Ohio St. - multi-year starter - 2-time All Big 10 1st team
2012
Jameis Winston - Florida St. - Heisman Trophy Winner - 1st round - Buccaneers
2013
None
2014
None
2001
D.J. Shockley - Georgia - First-Team All-SEC - 7th round - Falcons - NFL back-up for 4.5 years
Cecil Howard - Syracuse - no impact in college (transferred twice, ending up at Northeastern)
2002
Vince Young - Texas - consensus All-American - 1st round - Titans - 2-time Pro-Bowler
Marcus Vick - Virginia Tech - starter in 2005, but dismissed from team in 2006 because of legal troubles
James Banks - Tennessee - converted to WR, then transferred to Carson-Newman
2003
Robert Lane - Ole Miss - converted to H-Back/TE - not drafted
2004
Xavier Lee - Florida St. - had a few starts - not drafted
Matt Tuiasosopo - Washington - signed to play baseball, and has had stints with the Mariners and Tigers
Bobby Reid - Oklahoma St.- started for parts of 2 seasons - not drafted
2005
Ryan Perilloux - LSU - had a few promising starts - dismissed from LSU because of legal troubles and transferred to Jacksonville St. - not drafted - has made a few practice squads
2006
Tim Tebow - Florida - Heisman Trophy winner - odd NFL career
2007
Tyrod Taylor - Virginia Tech - multi-year starter and ACC player of the year - 6th round - Ravens - recently signed with the Bills
2008
Terrelle Pryor - Ohio St. - multi-year starter and runner up for Big 10 MVP - 3rd round (supplemental) - Raiders - recently converted to WR for the Browns
E.J. Manuel - Florida St. - multi-year started and 2nd team All-ACC - 1st round - Bills
2009
Russell Shepard - LSU - converted to WR - undrafted, but signed as free agent with Buccaneers - has played as a special teams player
Aaron Murray - Georgia - multi-year starter - SEC career passing leader - 5th round - Chiefs
2010
None
2011
Jeff Driskel - Florida - started a number of games, but not good - transferred to Louisiana Tech this year
Braxton Miller - Ohio St. - multi-year starter - 2-time All Big 10 1st team
2012
Jameis Winston - Florida St. - Heisman Trophy Winner - 1st round - Buccaneers
2013
None
2014
None
